5 Must-Try Lobster Rolls in The State of Maine

Maine Lobster Roll Quest: 5 Iconic Spots You Need to Try

Maine, the Pine Tree State, is synonymous with lobster. And while you can enjoy this prized crustacean in many forms, the undisputed king is the Maine lobster roll. This seemingly simple sandwich – fresh, sweet lobster meat piled onto a bun – inspires passionate debate and dedicated pilgrimages. From legendary roadside shacks to acclaimed city restaurants, finding the best lobster roll is a delicious journey. This article highlights five iconic and highly-regarded spots across Maine where you can experience lobster roll perfection.

1. Red's Eats (Wiscasset): The Legendary Overstuffed Roll

No list of Maine lobster rolls is complete without Red's Eats. This iconic red shack on coastal Route 1 has been a landmark since moving to Wiscasset in 1954 (after starting in Boothbay in the 1930s).

• What Makes It Special: Red's is famous for its incredibly generous portions – expect a heaping mound of fresh, unadorned lobster meat overflowing from a simple, toasted New England-style bun. You choose your side: butter or mayonnaise.
• The Experience: Be prepared for potentially long lines, especially during peak season. It's a rite of passage for many visitors. While they offer other seafood like lobster dogs and fried clams, the lobster roll is the star.

2. The Clam Shack (Kennebunkport): Award-Winning Waterfront Classic

A fixture in bustling Kennebunkport for over 50 years, The Clam Shack consistently ranks among New England's best.

• What Makes It Special: Situated right on the bridge over the Kennebunk River, this shack has earned national acclaim, including being named "America's Best Lobster Rolls" by Food & Wine Magazine. Their lobster roll features fresh-picked meat on a toasted, round bakery bun (not the typical split-top), offered with a drizzle of butter, a swipe of mayo, or both.
• The Experience: Enjoy your roll at picnic tables overlooking the water. They also have excellent clam chowder, fried seafood, and an adjacent seafood market for take-home goodies.

3. Five Islands Lobster Co. (Georgetown): Picturesque Setting, Pure Lobster

For a truly scenic lobster roll experience, head to Five Islands Lobster Co. on a working fishing wharf in Georgetown.

• What Makes It Special: This spot combines a classic lobster shack, an ice cream stand, and a restaurant with breathtaking ocean views. The focus here is on incredibly fresh lobster, steamed clams, and the natural beauty of the surroundings. The menu is straightforward, letting the quality of the seafood shine.
• The Experience: Enjoy your lobster roll (or steamed clams with seafood broth) at picnic tables overlooking the picturesque harbor and islands. It's quintessential Maine coastal charm.

4. Warren’s Lobster House (Kittery): Southern Maine Staple with River Views

A long-standing favorite in southern Maine, Warren's Lobster House in Kittery offers more than just a lobster roll; it's a full-service restaurant experience.

• What Makes It Special: Located on the shores of the Piscataqua River, Warren's boasts panoramic water views from its knotty pine dining room and deck. While known for their lobster specials, they offer an extensive menu including over 50 soup and salad bar selections, steaks, and other seafood. They also have a full-service bakery and a boat dock.
• The Experience: A more traditional restaurant setting compared to the shacks, offering a wide menu and great views, making it a popular choice for families and larger groups.

5. Eventide Oyster Co. (Portland): Modern Twist on a Classic

For a contemporary, chef-driven take on the lobster roll, Eventide Oyster Co. in Portland is a must-visit.

• What Makes It Special: Eventide ditches the traditional bun for a unique, homemade split-top steamed bun. The fresh lobster meat is tossed in a warm brown butter vinaigrette instead of cold mayo or melted butter. This innovative approach has earned national recognition.
• The Experience: Located just north of the Old Port, Eventide is also renowned for its incredible selection of fresh oysters from Maine and beyond, served with creative accompaniments. Expect a bustling, modern atmosphere. Takeout and delivery are also options.

Maine's lobster roll scene is as diverse as its coastline. From the overflowing simplicity of Red's Eats to the modern innovation of Eventide Oyster Co., each iconic spot offers a unique and delicious interpretation of this beloved dish. Whether you prefer your lobster dressed in butter, mayo, or a warm vinaigrette, served in a classic split-top or a round bun, a quest for the perfect Maine lobster roll is a guaranteed culinary adventure. Plan your trip, bring your appetite, and discover your personal favorite!