8 Best Must-Try Pizza Shops in Wisconsin

Best Pizza in WisconsinWISCONSIN -Whether you want to enjoy a meal with your family or grab a quick snack, you'll want to know where to find the best pizza in Wisconsin. There are many options to choose from, including fast food and more casual restaurants, so it's hard to narrow down your choice. Here are a few places to try.

Where To Find The Best Pizza in Wisconsin?
Photo: Transfer Pizzeria Café


Where To Find The Best Pizza in Wisconsin?

1. Transfer Pizzeria Café in Milwaukee WI

Located in the old Transfer Pharmacy building, this restaurant has an ambiance to match the food.  The woodwork is still present, and the stained glass has been preserved. The menu features a variety of pizza options and gluten-free choices. Drinks include draft beer and tasty wine. The atmosphere is casual and comfortable. The Transfer Pizzeria Cafe is a popular restaurant renowned for its creative pizza combinations. It has been an excellent food source for Milwaukee residents since its opening in 2008. It is a family-friendly restaurant, and they welcome kids of all ages. They serve supper and AM meals; you can order take-out and delivery.

2. Christianos Pizza in Green Lake WI

Located on the waterfront, Christianos Pizza makes pizza from the highest quality ingredients available.  You can order from the comfort of your own home using their online ordering system. The restaurant also offers gluten-free pizzas. Regardless of the size of your order, you will always receive top-notch customer service. The restaurant caters to the discerning palate, whether you are a traditional pepperoni fan or crave new and exciting toppings. Afterward, take a stroll down the waterfront to enjoy the scenery.

3. Pizza Brutta in Madison WI

Located in Madison, WI, Pizza Brutta is the perfect place for pizza enthusiasts.  Not only does it feature wood-fired Neapolitan pies, but they are also dedicated to using locally sourced ingredients. This is an excellent spot for a quick bite and people looking for a casual dining experience. The restaurant is run by a farmer's son who grew up just two blocks from the Middleton Hills location. He has worked at the Michael Fields Agricultural Institute and has served as a product manager at Organic Valley and Yale University. He is also an accomplished chef, and he has a keen eye for local foods.

The restaurant offers a variety of salads, including a "healthy" option that is safe for those with celiac disease. The menu also includes a classic Neapolitan pizza. The pies are made with house-made mozzarella and organic San Marzano tomatoes. They are crispy and light. They are available in various sizes, from the personal to the kids' size. They are also available for delivery.

4. Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza in Sister Bay WI

Wild Tomato is a family-friendly restaurant on the Sister Bay Waterfront that serves pizzas, appetizers, entrees, and desserts.  Its modern rustic design features exposed wood beams and corrugated metal accents. They use local Door County ingredients to create their classic and deluxe-style pizzas. Its drinks include draft beer and wine. Guests can also order specialty pizzas with toppings, like vegan sausage.

Owners Sara and Britton Unkefer started Wild Tomato in Sister Bay in 2005 and have expanded to two other locations in Door County, including Fish Creek and Baileys Harbor. The restaurants focus on using locally sourced, organic, and sustainable products. They are open year-round. In addition to its wood-fired pizzas, the restaurant offers several vegetarian and gluten-free options. Its bread basket includes cheese cracklins with marinara and herb focaccia, a garlic flatbread, olive, roasted garlic ciabatta, and balsamic and olive oil. The restaurant also offers breakfast sandwiches and pastries.

5. Polito’s Pizza in Wisconsin Rapids WI

Whether you're a pizza connoisseur or just looking for a quick bite, you can't go wrong at Polito's.  Known for its big, bold flavors and specialties, you're bound to find your next craving at this diner of epic proportions. The most popular location is in the heart of Wisconsin Rapids. Besides the food, you'll also be able to luxuriate in the state's largest indoor pool. It's not the wrong place to unwind after a long day at the office. they also offer a wide variety of classic Italian specialties, including the best pepperoni. Besides the standard offerings, you can choose specialty toppings, such as spicy sausage, feta, and bacon.

6. Ian’s Pizza in Milwaukee WI

Located in the heart of Milwaukee's downtown, Ian's Pizza is a must-try for a night out on the town.  The "Picked for You" menu boasts local and regional favorites, including a few gluten-friendly options, such as the pupu chow. This is also a great place to catch a game on one of the 16 classic arcade cabinet games. The decor is not too shabby, either. This is a sports-friendly venue, so you're sure to get a kick out of the atmosphere.

Although Ian's is best known for its specialty mac 'n' cheese pies, you'll also find some tasty pizzas on its menu and some more standard offerings. You'll also find several craft vegan and vegetarian dishes and a few classic beverages, including a hefty mug of kale and quinoa salad.

7. Winghaven Pizza Farm in Galesville WI

Visiting a Midwestern pizza farm can be a unique and fun experience.  These farms have been around for a few decades and are a weekend staple in towns across the Midwest. They are usually open on weekends and have live music and local beer. During the summer, Winghaven Pizza Farm is open on Friday and Saturday nights. The restaurant features an excellent wine and beer bar and live music. The setting is beautiful, with a valley in the middle of the restaurant. The staff is friendly, and the restaurant has lots of activities for kids. There are also lawn games for families before savoring their delicious pizza.

Winghaven pizza is made from locally sourced ingredients and served in a stone-fired pizza oven. The crust is cracker thin and incredibly sturdy. The cheese is Dairy-State sourced, and there is an excellent selection of pizzas. The pretzels are giant stone oven-baked and are topped with melted butter and Italian herbs. There is also a large selection of vegetarian pizzas.

8. Broken Tree Pizza in Neenah WI

Broken Tree Pizza (BTP) is a pizza and grub connoisseur's paradise in the heart of Wisconsin's apple country.  The establishment boasts a slick interior and a pleasantly sized menu. The company even makes its beer and wine. In addition to the usual suspects, the restaurant also serves as a venue for local bands and trivia nights.

The wood-fired pizzeria has been a long-time standby in the Neenah area but has become more of a hangout for affluent residents in recent years. The name carries a hefty price tag, but the quality is undeniable. The restaurant's wine list is impressive, and its beer list is worth the price of admission. The most important feature is customer service. The staff is friendly, and the service is fast and consistent. The one-to-one experience is a rarity in today's crowded field of chain restaurants. Thankfully, the restaurant has a shared entrance with other local establishments, making it easy to park and get your grub on.