8 Best Must-Try Restaurants in Indiana

Where are The Best Restaurants in IndianaINDIANA - I8tonite, an independent food website promoting local culinary talents, has recently unveiled its highly-anticipated list of the top Indiana-based restaurants for 2023. This remarkable compilation aims to rectify the frequent oversight by national outlets that often fail to acknowledge Indiana's exceptional chefs and eateries. Through a meticulous evaluation process, considering factors such as taste, execution, service, price, and atmosphere, the discerning food enthusiasts at I8tonite have carefully curated a selection of Indiana's most outstanding dining experiences.


8 Best Must-Try Restaurants in Indiana

Where are The Best Restaurants in Indiana


1. Lady Tron's

One of the highly-praised choices on I8tonite's list is Lady Tron's, a charming establishment tucked away in the scenic city of New Albany. Renowned for its imaginatively crafted sandwiches and awe-inspiring sci-fi-themed decor, Lady Tron's offers a unique and unforgettable dining experience.

2. Perrillo's Pizzeria

Perrillo's Pizzeria, situated in the enchanting town of New Salem, has carved out a niche by serving mouthwatering slices of Neapolitan and New York-style pizza. What sets Perrillo's apart is its dedication to sourcing locally grown ingredients, resulting in a rich and authentic flavor profile that keeps patrons returning for more.



3. Tinker Street Restaurant & Wine Bar

Tinker Street Restaurant & Wine Bar, located in bustling Indianapolis, focuses on utilizing locally grown produce, highlighting the exceptional quality of ingredients available within the state. Tinker Street offers meticulously selected wine pairings alongside their commitment to locally sourced ingredients, creating an unforgettable dining experience tantalizing the senses.

4. Chicken Scratch

Chicken Scratch, led by the talented Chef Tia Harrison, has become a sought-after destination for chicken wing enthusiasts in Indianapolis. With various tantalizing flavors, diners are treated to a flavor sensation that keeps them returning for more.



5. Anthony's Chophouse

For those seeking a sophisticated dining experience, Anthony's Chophouse in the charming town of Carmel delivers impeccable service and flawlessly prepared steaks that cater to the most discerning palates.

6. Petit Chou Bistro & Champagne Bar

Petit Chou Bistro & Champagne Bar, owned by the esteemed Martha Hoover and nestled in the heart of Indianapolis, transports diners to the enchanting world of French bistro cuisine. With an emphasis on impeccable service and authentic flavors, this establishment has become a must-visit for culinary enthusiasts.

7. Love Handle

Love Handle, a trendy and vibrant eatery in Indianapolis, offers a lively atmosphere and messy yet undeniably delicious food. It has become a popular spot for those seeking delectably messy bites paired with a stylish ambiance.

8. 9th Street Bistro

Lastly, Chef Samir Mohammed's 9th Street Bistro in Noblesville takes diners on a global flavor-filled journey, effortlessly fusing international influences with a comforting taste of home.




The selection of these esteemed restaurants exemplifies Indiana's diverse and vibrant culinary landscape. By serving innovative dishes, embracing local ingredients, and providing outstanding service, these establishments have earned their place on I8tonite's prestigious list and solidified their status as trailblazers in Indiana's ever-evolving dining scene. With their dedication to culinary excellence, these eateries have undoubtedly made Indiana a destination for food lovers seeking exceptional dining experiences.