5 Best Pizza Restaurants in West Virginia

A Slice of the Mountain State: 5 Best Pizza Restaurants in West Virginia

West Virginia's culinary landscape is full of delicious surprises, and its pizza scene is no exception. Beyond pepperoni rolls and classic Appalachian comfort food, the state is home to a diverse array of pizzerias serving up everything from unique regional styles to gourmet wood-fired pies. Whether you're a local resident or a traveler exploring the state's natural beauty, finding a fantastic slice of pizza is never far away. Here is a guide to five of the best and most beloved pizza spots across West Virginia.

1. Pies & Pints (Fayetteville & other locations)

• The Pizza: A craft beer and pizza powerhouse, Pies & Pints has earned widespread acclaim for its creative and high-quality pies. They are known for unique combinations and using fresh, interesting ingredients that go far beyond standard toppings. It's a must-visit for anyone seeking a gourmet pizza experience.
• The Vibe: A lively and popular pub atmosphere with a fantastic, extensive selection of craft beers on tap. Its Fayetteville location is a particularly popular spot for visitors to the nearby New River Gorge National Park and Preserve to relax and refuel after a day of adventure.
• Location Example: 219 W Maple Ave, Fayetteville, WV 25840

2. DiCarlo's Pizza (Wheeling & other locations)

• The Pizza: DiCarlo's Pizza is a legendary institution and the originator of the unique Ohio Valley style pizza. The process is distinct: a square or rectangular crust is baked with sauce, and then cold cheese (typically provolone) and other toppings are added after it comes out of the oven. The heat from the crust melts the cheese just enough, creating a one-of-a-kind texture and flavor profile.
• The Vibe: A classic, no-frills pizzeria with a rich history dating back to its founding in Steubenville, Ohio, in 1945. The Wheeling locations are a local favorite, run by the DiCarlo family and steeped in tradition.
• Location Example: 1311 Main St, Wheeling, WV 26003

3. Pizza & Cream (Nebo, Clay County)

• The Pizza: This charming spot in the small community of Nebo serves up the best of both worlds: delicious wood-fired pizza and homemade ice cream. The menu offers a mix of traditional and not-so-traditional pies, like a New York-style pizza with bacon and cheddar. They also feature gourmet sandwiches.
• The Vibe: A cozy and welcoming eatery with a fantastic outdoor patio and a well-stocked bar featuring craft beer and specialty sodas. It's a true hidden gem perfect for a scenic drive and a rewarding meal.
• Location: 215 Nebo Rd, Nebo, WV 25141

4. Sirianni's Pizza Café (Davis)

• The Pizza: A beloved local favorite in the mountain town of Davis since 1988, Sirianni's Pizza Cafe is a family-run shop known for its welcoming atmosphere and delicious range of pizzas and Italian-American bites.
• The Vibe: This cafe is celebrated for its fine decor and exceptional, cozy atmosphere, making it a perfect spot to unwind after hiking, skiing, or exploring the surrounding Canaan Valley. The menu also includes a large selection of salads and appetizers like stuffed peppers.
• Location: 474 William Ave, Davis, WV 26260

5. Montese's Pizza (Martinsburg)

• The Pizza: Montese's is a family-friendly restaurant in Martinsburg offering a wide variety of food, with its pizza being a central draw. They are particularly well-known for their pizza buffet, which provides a fantastic array of options for diners to sample.
• The Vibe: A perfect spot for families or anyone with a big appetite. The buffet is well-maintained and includes old-fashioned salads and other novelty fares alongside colossal pizzas. They also offer takeout and pickup options.
• Location: 830 E Moler Ave, Martinsburg, WV 25404

West Virginia's pizza scene is a delicious reflection of the state's diverse character. From the unique Ohio Valley style served at DiCarlo's to the gourmet craft pies at Pies & Pints and the rustic charm of Pizza & Cream, there's a phenomenal slice waiting in every corner of the Mountain State. So next time you're exploring, be sure to seek out one of these top-rated pizzerias for a truly satisfying meal.