FLORIDA - Pizza lovers in Fort Myers, Florida, rejoice! The search for the perfect slice can be an exciting journey, and we've rounded up ten of the top pizza shops in the area that are sure to satisfy your cravings in 2025. Whether you prefer a classic New York-style pie, a deep-dish delight, or something a little more unique, Fort Myers has a pizza for every palate.
Here are our top 10 picks for pizza in Fort Myers
1. Uncle Rico's Pizza
This pizzeria frequently receives high praise for its amazing crust and sauce, particularly their New York-style pizza. It's a local favorite known for quality ingredients and authentic flavors.
2. Downtown House of Pizza (DHOP)
Located in the heart of downtown Fort Myers, DHOP is a go-to spot for many seeking authentic New York-style pizza. Reviewers rave about their delicious pies and consider it one of the best in the county.
3. Heavenly Pizza
As the name suggests, Heavenly Pizza in North Fort Myers aims to deliver a slice of heaven. They're known for fresh, delicious pizzas, homemade soups, salads, and sub rolls, and have been recognized as the "Best Pizza of North Fort Myers."
4. Bella Mia Pizza & Restaurant
This establishment offers more than just pizza, but their pies come highly recommended. It's a place where you can enjoy a full Italian meal alongside a tasty pizza.
5. Little Sicily
With a high rating and positive reviews, Little Sicily seems to be a reliable choice for those craving Sicilian-style pizza and other Italian dishes.
6. Baked (Formerly Buddyz)
Known for really good pizza and even hot dogs, Baked offers a casual and satisfying dining experience.
7. Grimaldi's Coal Brick-Oven Pizzeria
While part of a larger chain, Grimaldi's in Fort Myers delivers on the promise of delicious, coal-fired brick oven pizza, offering a unique and flavorful crust.
8. Bellacino's Pizza & Grinders
f you're looking for more than just pizza, Bellacino's also specializes in grinders (subs) but their pizza is a solid contender with a variety of toppings.
9. Marco's Pizza
A well-known national chain, Marco's in Fort Myers maintains a reputation for quality and consistent pizza, offering both delivery and carryout options.
10. Jet's Pizza
Famous for its deep-dish pizza with crispy, caramelized crust, Jet's is a great option for those who prefer a Detroit-style pie. They also offer other styles and toppings to choose from.
Whether you're a local or just visiting Fort Myers, this list should give you a great starting point for finding your next favorite pizza spot. Happy eating!
