FLORIDA - When the sun beats down on Key West's tropical paradise, there's no better way to cool off than with a scoop (or two!) of delicious ice cream. Fortunately, the island has many ice cream shops, each offering a unique twist on this classic treat. Key West's ice cream scene will satisfy even the most discerning sweet tooth, from homemade classics to innovative nitrogen-infused creations.Key West's Ice Cream Paradise: A Guide to the Island's Sweetest Treats
1. Mattheessen's Candy Kitchen
A Key West tradition since 1949, Mattheessen's Candy Kitchen is a must-visit for ice cream lovers. Step back in time and experience the charm of old Florida as you browse its classic and tropical ice cream flavors. Their commitment to using high-quality ingredients shines through in every lick, whether you opt for a timeless favorite like vanilla bean or a taste of the tropics with their mango or coconut cream ice cream. Don't miss their signature Key lime pie ice cream, a tangy and refreshing tribute to the island's most famous dessert. Mattheessen's also offers a delectable selection of homemade chocolates and candies, making it a one-stop shop for satisfying your sweet tooth.
2. Kilwins
Step into a world of handcrafted chocolates and premium ice cream made in small batches at Kilwins on Duval Street. Don't miss their famous Turtle Sundae, a decadent masterpiece featuring layers of vanilla ice cream, rich caramel sauce, hot fudge, and toasted pecans, all topped with a generous dollop of whipped cream and a maraschino cherry. While you're there, take a moment to watch skilled candy makers create colorful confections through the large viewing windows. The mesmerizing process of transforming molten sugar into whimsical shapes and delectable treats is delightful.
3. Gladiators Ice Cream
Prepare to have your taste buds embark on a flavor adventure at Gladiators Ice Cream. Their flavor creations are anything but ordinary. Gone are the days of vanilla and chocolate (although they do have those, too, for the purists). Instead, get ready to tantalize your taste buds with scoops of Key Lime Pie, a symphony of tart and creamy, or Salted Caramel Truffle, a decadent blend of sweet and salty. But that's just the tip of the iceberg. Gladiators' menu is a constantly evolving playground of flavor possibilities, with new and exciting creations dreamt up by their passionate team of ice cream artisans. They use only the freshest, locally sourced ingredients to create their ice cream masterpieces, ensuring a quality and taste that shines through in every lick.
4. Wicked Lick
Step into the future of ice cream at Wicked Lick. Here, liquid nitrogen takes center stage, transforming fresh ingredients into super-smooth, ultra-creamy concoctions. The menu is a wonderland of ever-changing flavors, from classic favorites like chocolate chip cookie dough and cookies and cream to more adventurous options like mango habanero and lavender honey. No matter your preference, Wicked Lick guarantees a delightful surprise with every visit. Watch in amazement as the staff flash-freezes your chosen ingredients with liquid nitrogen, creating a cloud of frosty vapor before transforming them into a decadent scoop of ice cream. The result? It is a textural experience that is intensely flavorful and so smooth that it melts on your tongue.
5. Rooster Treats
Soft Serve Ice Cream & Mini Donuts: Return to a simpler time with a visit to Rooster Treats. This retro-inspired shop offers a delightful combination of homemade soft-serve ice cream and warm mini donuts, perfect for creating your customized sweet masterpiece. Choose from various toppings like sprinkles, hot fudge, and whipped cream to create a flavor explosion that will tantalize your taste buds. Whether you prefer a classic vanilla and chocolate combination or a more adventurous mix-in like peanut butter and banana, Rooster Treats offers endless possibilities for sweet satisfaction.And don't forget the mini donuts! These melt-in-your-mouth treats are made fresh daily and dusted with cinnamon sugar for an extra touch of deliciousness. They're the perfect complement to your soft-serve ice cream or can be enjoyed individually for a quick and satisfying sugary bite.
6. Flamingo Crossing
A cornerstone of the Key West ice cream scene since 1987, Flamingo Crossing is a family-owned haven for ice cream lovers. Their commitment to using high-quality ingredients and fresh produce shines through in their delectable flavors. From classics like chocolate chip cookie dough and butter pecan to island-inspired creations like guava and coconut, Flamingo Crossing offers a taste of paradise in every scoop. Their generous portions and warm hospitality make it a favorite among locals and tourists. Don't miss their signature Key Lime Pie ice cream, a tangy and refreshing tribute to the island's most famous dessert.
Key West's ice cream scene offers something for everyone. Whether you are seeking a nostalgic experience, innovative flavors, or a playful treat on a sunny day, these shops will satisfy your cravings and give you a sweet memory of your island getaway. So indulge in a scoop (or two!) – you deserve it.
