OHIO - Cincinnati’s food scene is famous for its chili, but its pizza game is equally diverse and fiercely debated. From the unique "local style" with mounds of cold cheese to artisanal wood-fired pies, the Queen City offers a slice for every palate.
Whether you are a lifelong resident or just visiting for a Reds game, these are the top pizzerias in Cincinnati you need to try in 2026.
1. LaRosa’s Family Pizzeria
You cannot talk about Cincinnati pizza without starting with LaRosa’s. It is a local institution with a flavor profile that is distinct to the region.
- The Style: Known for its thin, slightly sweet crust and a signature sauce that leans into a herbal, sweeter profile.
- The "Pro" Move: Order the "Buddy Deluxe" and don't forget a side of their famous garlic fries.
2. Taglio
If you are looking for the perfect Detroit-style deep dish in the Midwest, Taglio is the gold standard. With locations in Columbia Tusculum and Over-the-Rhine (OTR), it has quickly become a local favorite for a more indulgent meal.
- The Style: Thick, airy crust with caramelized cheesy edges and sauce striped across the top.
- Must Order: The Hot Honey pepperoni pie—the balance of spice and sweetness is legendary.
3. Adriatico’s New York Style Pizza
Located near the University of Cincinnati, Adriatico’s is a rite of passage for students and locals alike. It is consistently voted one of the best in the city for those who crave a massive, traditional slice.
- The Style: True New York-style thin crust, but they are most famous for their "Bearcat" size—a giant rectangular pizza that can feed an entire party.
- Must Order: The "Inflatiatico" if you’re feeling brave, or stick to a classic pepperoni slice.
4. Catch-a-Fire Pizza
Born in a food truck and now anchored in Blue Ash and Lebanon, Catch-a-Fire brings a wood-fired, gourmet touch to the Cincinnati pizza scene.
- The Style: Neapolitan-inspired with a smoky, charred crust.
- The Vibe: They often share space with local breweries (like MadTree), making it the perfect spot for a casual weekend hangout.
- Must Order: The "One Love" (their take on a classic Margherita) or the "Zion" for something more adventurous.
5. Strong’s Brick Oven Pizzeria
Technically located just across the river in Newport and Union (but a staple of the Cincinnati dining circuit), Strong’s offers an old-school, authentic brick-oven experience.
- The Style: Thin, crispy, and cooked at high heat to achieve that perfect fold.
- Must Order: The "Pizza alla Vodka" or the "Quattro Formaggi."
6. Fireside Pizza
Located in a restored 19th-century firehouse in Walnut Hills, this spot offers one of the coolest dining atmospheres in the city.
- The Style: Artisanal wood-fired pies with a focus on fresh, high-quality toppings.
- Must Order: The "Greek" or their seasonal specials which often feature locally sourced produce.
The "Cincinnati Style" Debate: To Bake or Not to Bake?
If you really want to eat like a local, you have to try Ramundo’s or Marion's Piazza (closer to Dayton but with a local cult following). Some local spots are famous for the "cold cheese" technique—adding a fresh handful of shredded provolone to the hot pizza after it comes out of the oven so it melts slowly as you eat it.
Quick Guide for Your Pizza Cravings:
- For a Crowd: Adriatico’s (The Bearcat size is a crowd-pleaser).
- For a Date Night: Taglio OTR or Catch-a-Fire.
- For the Kids: LaRosa’s (The family-friendly atmosphere is unbeatable).