Not too many places like this exist anymore. The location itself is incredible—many visitors, including us, love to walk along the jetty before or after dinner to take in the endless horizons. Whether you choose waterside or inside dining, the sweeping panoramic views create an atmosphere that cannot be matched.
Fresh Catch: Scallops, Salmon, and Excellent Wine
The culinary team at Oakland's consistently delivers fresh, beautifully prepared seafood. Diners praise the kitchen for its focus on quality, and the menu reflects the bounty of the local waterways.
- Scallops and Salmon: The seafood execution is top-notch, with standout dishes like perfectly cooked scallops and fresh salmon drawing consistent praise from guests.
- Fresh Lobster: Of course, no trip to Oakland's is complete without indulging in their all-time favorite—fresh lobster.
- Good Quality Wine: The beverage program perfectly complements the menu, offering great cocktails and good quality wines from their award-winning list.
Everything we ordered arrived fresh, flavorful, and wonderfully presented, confirming that this is a kitchen that cares about the details.
Friendly Service, Sunsets, and Managing the Wait
A waterfront restaurant relies heavily on its hospitality to keep the mood relaxed, and the reception and service here are consistently friendly, professional, and accommodating. The staff creates an environment that feels welcoming and decidedly "not stuffy," allowing you to unwind truly.
Because the restaurant is known for its unforgettable sunsets—truly among the best you'll ever experience on the East End—it lures big crowds. It is important to note that Oakland's operates as a walk-in only establishment for both indoor and outdoor dining. During peak summer hours, this can mean long wait times. However, grabbing a drink by the water while you wait makes the time pass quickly, and the overall experience is well worth your patience.
The Verdict
Oakland's Restaurant is a true Hampton Bays treasure. Between the incredible fresh scallops and salmon, the beautiful sunset views over Shinnecock Inlet, and the exceptionally friendly staff, this Dune Road destination delivers an outstanding coastal dining experience. I am absolutely grateful to have a place like this still around—thank you to the owners and the staff for keeping the magic of summer dining alive!